[h] home [b] blog [n] notebook

2 mistakes when valuing time

There's a popular framework in productivity circles. Calculate your hourly rate, then outsource anything that costs less per hour than you earn. Sounds clean. Sounds rational. And it leads to two mistakes I see constantly.

Mistake 1: Treating All Hours as Equal

The hourly rate calculation assumes your time is fungible. That an hour saved doing laundry is an hour gained doing high-value work. But that's rarely true. If I pay someone to clean my apartment, I don't spend that freed-up hour writing code or closing deals. I spend it scrolling my phone or taking a slightly longer lunch.

The real question isn't "what's my hourly rate?" It's "what will I actually do with the time I save?" If the answer is "nothing particularly valuable," then the calculation breaks down. You haven't bought time. You've bought the illusion of time.

The hours that are actually fungible, the ones where you'd genuinely redirect freed time into something meaningful, are much rarer than people think. Most of us have maybe 3 or 4 hours of peak cognitive output per day. The rest is filler regardless of what we outsource.

Mistake 2: Ignoring the Value of Doing

The second mistake is subtler. Some tasks have value beyond their output. Cooking dinner isn't just about producing food. It's a transition ritual between work and evening. Walking to the grocery store isn't just about acquiring groceries. It's ambient exercise, spontaneous encounters, a change of scenery.

The hourly rate framework treats these activities as pure cost centers. But they're often the things that make a life feel like a life, rather than an optimization problem.

I've met people who've optimized away every "low-value" task and find themselves wealthy, efficient, and vaguely miserable. They've outsourced their way into a life that looks great on a spreadsheet and feels like nothing.

A Better Frame

Instead of asking "is this worth my hourly rate?" I try to ask two different questions:

First: "Do I enjoy this?" If yes, the economic calculation is irrelevant. You don't need a financial justification to do things you like.

Second: "What will I genuinely do instead?" Not what you could do. What you will do. Be honest. If the answer is "something better," outsource away. If the answer is "more of the same nothing," maybe the task itself was the best use of that hour all along.